Lawmakers may solve Utah’s problem with outlaw AirBNBs and improve affordable housing in the state in the process. Robert Gehrke explains.


Editor’s be aware • This story is accessible to Salt Lake Tribune subscribers solely. Thanks for supporting native journalism.

Don’t get me incorrect: I like short-term leases.

However final 12 months, I wrote about an actual drawback: The exploding short-term rental market in Utah was exacerbating an already-untenable housing scarcity within the state.

What’s extra, a good portion of those short-term leases are situated in locations the place cities say they’re not allowed because of zoning restrictions, however the Legislature had tied cities’ fingers, passing laws 5 years in the past prohibiting municipalities from implementing the zoning restrictions by happening an Airbnb or VRBO web site and figuring out unlawful leases.

As a substitute, they needed to wait for one more violation — a noise criticism from a neighbor or a police name.

Which will lastly be about to vary.

On Wednesday, Rep. Steve Waldrip, R-Eden, launched a significant inexpensive housing invoice with a variety of good provisions (extra on these later), together with the final strains of the measure, which might repeal the foolish restriction on how cities are allowed to crack down on unlawful short-term leases.

(Rick Egan | The Salt Lake Tribune) Rep. Steve Waldrip discusses the air high quality laws and appropriations requests in the course of the 2021 Normal Session, together with the Utah LegislatureÕs bipartisan Clear Air Caucus, throughout a information convention on the steps of the Capitol, on Wednesday, Feb. 10, 2021.

After I wrote my piece final 12 months, I received a variety of blowback from short-term rental hosts and the property rights crowd.

“Though I perceive your whole complaints, I disagree that authorities ought to have any management over what anybody does with their non-public property,” one reader wrote about my piece. “Solely a liberal would counsel that authorities management and intervene with what residents do with non-public property. … Folks such as you disgust me.”

Waldrip will in all probability get a few of that very same flack. And I perceive those that assume: What’s the massive deal if I let somebody hire a dwelling for a number of nights?

Effectively, for one factor, they’re unlawful. And, as Waldrip — who just isn’t a liberal — explains, they will disrupt communities.

“Whereas they’re an incredible device in the fitting location, within the incorrect areas, they will trigger some issues with the neighborhoods and communities the place they’re not zoned for it,” he mentioned. “There’s an expectation when folks transfer right into a neighborhood and the zoning is such that they’re not allowed. After they change into prevalent and alter the neighborhood, you may have an entire totally different really feel.”

Then there’s the sheer scope of the market and its affect on Utah’s total housing image. There are 19,000 short-term rental items statewide, in response to the Kem Gardner Coverage Institute. Every of these is a rental unit {that a} Utahn may in any other case name house. Waldrip mentioned an estimated 30% of them should not legally located.

The issue is particularly acute in resort communities like Park Metropolis, the place greater than a 3rd of the constructions on the town are short-term leases and the town has lower than 1 / 4 of the inexpensive housing it wants.

“In the event you take these leases which can be inappropriately held for in a single day leases and put them again into the housing market, you’re speaking a few vital variety of housing items coming again into the market,” Waldrip mentioned.

Transferring these 5,700 items again into the long-term leases may assist put a significant dent within the estimated 55,000-unit scarcity in single-family houses, residences and different sorts of housing throughout the state.

Clearly, it doesn’t clear up your complete drawback. That’s the place the remainder of Waldrip’s invoice is available in.

The cornerstone of the invoice is a list of moderate-income housing statewide, so we are able to establish the most important drawback areas, set targets for a way a lot every neighborhood must be contributing to the answer after which commit sources to attending to that purpose. And it comes with sources, in search of $50 million for the Olene Walker Housing fund.

Below the invoice, cities could be required to submit particular methods to develop inexpensive housing and prioritize the cash to these keen to be most aggressive concerning the mission. A revision, Waldrip mentioned, will direct communities to construct round Trax, FrontRunner and bus corridors.

It places one other $50 million right into a rural housing mortgage fund aimed toward serving to bolster investments in housing and pay for labor in locations which can be quick on each.

“As unhealthy as the issue is alongside the Wasatch Entrance, I believe it’s much more acute in rural Utah,” Waldrip mentioned. “We have now communities in rural Utah the place they’ve two or three houses obtainable however they’ve 150 to 200 job openings.”

There are different good components to the invoice, too, like a requirement that 20% of the housing on the previous state jail website be allotted to moderate-income occupants. It’s a superb piece of laws, probably a game-changer. And it’s certain to ruffle some feathers of those that are fed up with extra building and extra housing density and assume it erodes their high quality of life.

However as Waldrip sees it, his invoice seeks to verify our subsequent era can afford to dwell right here and protect Utah’s high quality of life.

“We have now to begin preaching … that for the primary time because the pioneers, in-migration to Utah final 12 months was better than our native progress,” he mentioned. “If we need to destroy the standard of life in Utah, the quickest path is to export our children as a result of they don’t have housing and import folks from different locations who can afford actually costly housing.”

Could plastic made from bacteria guts help solve our waste crisis? | NOVA



Tech + EngineeringTech & Engineering

Bioplastics referred to as PHAs develop like beer and biodegrade like wooden. And they are able to assist with our plastic waste drawback.

Ingesting straws are one in every of many single-use plastic merchandise that would doubtlessly be produced utilizing biopolymers. Picture Credit score: Phichai, Shutterstock

Regardless of the efforts of recycling packages and environmental schooling, it’s nonetheless exhausting for many people to know simply how a lot plastic people produce. We’re on observe to provide a billion tons of plastic a yr by 2050. Cumulatively, we’ve already produced greater than 8.3 billion metric tons since 1950. That’s 20 instances the burden of all human beings alive proper now. 

The programs we’ve developed for recycling that plastic are filled with logistical, political, and financial obstacles, and the numbers present it. By 2015, three quarters of these 8 billion metric tons of plastic had been already out of use, with 9% of it having been recycled and 12% incinerated. A whopping 79% wound up in landfills or the pure surroundings, destined to take a seat nearly unchanged for a whole lot, if not hundreds, of years.

It doesn’t should be this fashion. “Plastic” is a class that encompasses an enormous variety of supplies with one factor in frequent: They’re product of repeating chains of molecules referred to as “polymers” and will be molded or extruded whereas tender to take explicit shapes. Till lately, we have solely seemed to petrochemicals (constituted of crude oil and pure gasoline) to create plastics with the properties we discover so helpful: the rigidity of takeout utensils, the pliability of plastic movies, the moisture barrier that incorporates greasy meals. Though some less-common petroplastics are certainly biodegradable, bioplastics—which are sometimes constituted of plant supplies like sugar cane pulp, corn, or cassava and in lots of circumstances biodegrade after comparatively brief intervals—may have the ability to assist deal with our massive plastic drawback.

Enter polyhydroxyalkanoates, also called PHAs, polymers used to make biodegradable bioplastics from an unlikely supply: micro organism guts. PHAs and different bioplastics search to problem our assumptions about what plastic will be, and firms like Danimer in Georgia and Mango Supplies in California are betting massive that their merchandise may also help make a dent in our plastic waste numbers. Danimer’s partnership with Bacardi will see that firm unveiling PHA bottles in all of its liquor traces by 2023; it additionally has partnerships within the works with Nestle, Pepsico, and different giants of single-use plastic. In the meantime, Mango is making inroads into different plastic-reliant industries, like attire. (Sure, your exercise garments have plastic in them.)

However PHAs aren’t new. They’ve been round for 35 years, and doubters prefer to level to Metabolix, a PHA firm that appeared promising, grew rapidly, after which collapsed in 2016. Metabolix and different would-be innovators have lived and died making an attempt to “make PHAs occur.” Is now the time for this bioplastic to interrupt by way of?

You may not suppose plastic and beer have a lot in frequent, however within the case of PHAs, there’s some shocking overlap. The bio-based plastic is derived from what quantities to micro organism guts, a polymer the microorganisms use to show meals into power saved away for a wet day. To make that polymer into one thing usable for people, PHA scientists and entrepreneurs develop the micro organism in massive vats beneath particular circumstances, feeding them with vegetable oil, sugar, or methane gasoline and ready to reap the outcomes. Thus far, kinda like beer.

Right here’s the place it will get a little bit completely different. When the micro organism have gotten so full and roly-poly that they’re barely micro organism anymore—when their cells have gone from round 3% polymer to upwards of 95%—they’re topic to a purification course of that bursts their membranes and brings the polymer out of resolution. The ensuing white powder is mixed in pellets that then will be made into straws and takeout containers. Voila: plastic that’s not simply made with out fossil fuels however can also be totally compostable, biodegrading in each your yard and the ocean.

We’ve recognized about micro organism’s capability to fabricate plastic because the Nineteen Twenties. But it surely took till 1983 to determine the right way to get the polymers from contained in the micro organism into human fingers and till fairly lately for that to occur on a scale that may very well be commercialized. “If you happen to consider what we knew within the early twentieth century about micro organism, microscopy, evolution, all these issues have quickly advanced,” says Mango Supplies CEO Molly Morse. Solely within the final decade have we had the instrument set to make PHAs a actuality.

Pellets constituted of PHA biopolymers. Photograph courtesy of Mango Supplies

Now, there are over 150 forms of PHAs, which differ based mostly on the size of their molecules, how they’re structured, which microorganisms are producing them, and what these microorganisms are fed. The longer the molecule chains, the extra versatile and stretchable the plastic is; the shorter they’re, the extra brittle the fabric turns into. PHAs soften and move like petroplastics and they are often become sheets or molded into many kinds. That makes them nice for all types of purposes with one factor in frequent: whether or not in yard compost, in industrial composting services, or within the ocean, they’ll fully biodegrade inside six months. 

The large distinction is that petroplastics are artificial, and whereas micro organism could try to interrupt them down, these organisms lack enzymes to interrupt the plastics’ carbon-carbon bonds, making full degradation not possible. However since micro organism already use PHAs to retailer power, they’ve built-in methods to each acknowledge and break them down. That’s what makes PHAs uniquely biodegradable—however solely in particular settings. To know why that is potential, “take into consideration wooden,” says Danimer Chief Expertise Officer Phil Van Trump. If you happen to construct your desk out of wooden, it gained’t simply disappear out of your own home sooner or later; it wants the proper surroundings for that. “However in your yard, it’s a special story. Put it again in that surroundings, and micro organism and fungi will acknowledge it as meals and begin in on it.”

After all, there are some drawbacks. In plastic-nerd parlance, PHAs have a “slender processing window,” which implies that their melting level and the purpose at which warmth transforms them chemically into one thing else are solely 10 levels aside. That limits the methods they are often processed to face in for petroplastics—for instance, in supplies which can be subjected to very excessive warmth or want very excessive mechanical power, like airplane windshields, automobile bumpers, or bulletproof vests. However PHAs’ largest downside is value. Manufacturing is comparatively costly, particularly the a part of the method that attracts the polymer out of the micro organism, says Amar Mohanty, a polymer and plastics engineer on the College of Guelph in Canada. Although there are completely different strategies for doing so, they typically require giant quantities of high-priced chemical substances like acetone or chloroform. “And to get a extremely purified polymer, it’s good to repeat the steps two or thrice,” provides his colleague, fellow engineer Manjusri Misra.

PHAs, like different bioplastics, additionally launch methane once they degrade beneath anaerobic circumstances (like in landfills). Since methane is a serious contributor to greenhouse gasoline emissions, some critics fear that if PHA merchandise develop in style after which are improperly disposed of, they could find yourself contributing to the local weather disaster. In response, Van Trump and Mohanty stress the significance of growing correct waste-disposal infrastructure together with PHA know-how, together with industrial composting and digesters. “There’s rising we have to do as a society with how a lot we stick in landfills,” Van Trump says. 

In her work at Mango Supplies, Morse has taken the methane launch subject in a special route, since Mango’s PHA micro organism really feed on methane to develop their polymer. Mango has even partnered with Silicon Valley Clear Water in Redwood Metropolis, California, to construct a digester on web site and harness the methane coming off the town’s waste. At simply that single location, Mango might produce as much as 10 million kilos of PHA plastic per yr.

After which there’s the query of toxicity. In a current examine, Lisa Zimmerman, a biologist at Goethe College in Germany, examined 40 completely different bioplastics, together with one PHA product, and located they weren’t on common any much less poisonous than common plastics. And when chemical substances from the bioplastics leached into an surroundings the place Zimmerman was elevating microorganisms, a lot of them (together with these from the PHA product) exhibited the potential to simulate hormones and interrupt the organisms’ metabolisms. Since a number of the merchandise she examined had been not poisonous, Zimmerman sees her outcome as an impetus to extend business transparency. “The issue is that the product composition is just not made overtly obtainable, so it’s actually exhausting for different producers to combine these much less dangerous chemical substances,” she says. “To scale up, it will actually assist if it was overtly communicated what’s within the product.” 

Plastic caps (left) and movie (proper) produced from PHA biopolymers. Pictures courtesy of Mango Supplies

Nonetheless, all of the individuals interviewed for this text see the present second as a time with monumental potential for bioplastics. As lately as 2014, when Mango utilized for funding by way of the Nationwide Science Basis to work on marine plastic air pollution, their utility was denied as a result of the inspiration “didn’t imagine plastics within the ocean had been an issue,” Morse says. She’s seen enormous societal change since then, even noticing a distinction simply throughout the interval of the COVID-19 pandemic. “Individuals are at residence gazing their trash cans questioning the place all these items goes,” she says. “We’ve seen curiosity prior to now 12 months like by no means earlier than.”

Van Trump additionally sees a serious change within the attitudes of the firms Danimer is partnering with, like Pepsi, Nestle, and Bacardi, which now appear extra prepared to put money into options to the plastics drawback. “We’re rising like a weed,” he says of Danimer, which simply opened new services in Georgia and Kentucky. And Van Trump and Morse each level out that worth and scale are intimately linked. Bioplastics like PHAs are competing towards a petroplastics business producing in merely monumental volumes, with some single vegetation producing a billion kilos a yr—and economies of scale make it potential for petroplastics corporations to maintain their costs low. “The business has had 70 to 80 years to optimize and construct capability,” Van Trump says. He holds out hope, although, that “after we get to the scales of the ‘conventional’ polymers, then prices will come down dramatically.”

In actual fact, Mohanty says the present drawback for PHAs is the other of what it was within the days of Metabolix: an excessive amount of demand and never sufficient manufacturing capability. He expects the business will develop into that demand within the coming decade, particularly as widespread single-use petroplastic bans go into impact. The important thing, within the meantime, is to coach shoppers about their choices and to construct sufficient infrastructure that each one these new PHA containers and movies and straws don’t find yourself in landfills. Of our voracious plastic urge for food, he says, “If we can not avoid it, we’ve to search out methods to deal with it.”

Here’s how Utah is finding new ways to solve an old problem: Hunger


Typically the numbers are huge — like 410,000, the variety of Utahns who’re “meals insecure,” which means they don’t know for sure the place their subsequent meal is coming from, in response to the Utah Meals Financial institution.

Typically the numbers are small — like $12, the value of two kilos of hamburger, as Ginette Bott, the meals financial institution’s president, seen on a current journey to the grocery retailer.

“In case you have a whole lot of youngsters, that’s perhaps one meal,” stated Bott, who’s extremely attuned to how such a worth will hit the households who go to the meals financial institution’s warehouse for emergency meals.

The efforts to assist households who’re meals insecure additionally are available in all sizes, from offering 1000’s of meals a day to serving only a few households at a time. And people working in opposition to meals insecurity can all the time use assist.

[Read more: Two Utah food pantries are closing. Blame red tape.]

The Utah Meals Financial institution, based in 1904 and now serving all 29 counties within the state, offers in huge quantities of meals. Final 12 months, the meals financial institution distributed 70.2 million kilos of meals, 58.5 million meals.

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Volunteer teams are recurrently scheduled to assist type and assemble meals on the Utah Meals Financial institution warehouse in South Salt Lake as seen on Wednesday, Feb. 16, 2022.

When households come to get meals, Bott stated, the meals financial institution doesn’t ask a whole lot of questions. Recipients don’t want to supply a social safety quantity, say what their revenue is, and even give an handle. The purpose, she stated, is to present support as rapidly and instantly as attainable.

“We ask how many individuals stay in your family, and we ask what number of of these are beneath 18 so we all know what number of youngsters,” she stated. “That’s all we have to know, and folks can get meals.”

Within the final two years, because the COVID-19 pandemic has continued, Bott stated the meals financial institution has seen 3 times the variety of households as earlier than the pandemic.

“Proper now, we simply don’t appear to have any aid,” she stated, citing the totally different bills which can be rising for Utah households, together with meals, reasonably priced housing and daycare. “We see, on a regular basis, two and three households residing collectively. … It’s nice to have that assist construction and do this, however that’s a whole lot of bills they’re attempting to fulfill.”

A enterprise provides again

Vivi and Amy Wanderley-Britt, who head the 360 Levels Restaurant Group, say social justice is a part of their mission.

At their three eating places — Salt Lake Metropolis’s Pig in a Jelly Jar, Pig Kitchen in Holladay, and Ogden’s WB’s Eatery — the couple sells espresso and jam, with proceeds going to Nuzzles & Co. pet rescue, and vintage-style socks that increase cash for ladies’s shelters. They pay their service workers an hourly wage, fairly than counting on suggestions — and any money left on the tables goes to a program near Vivi Wanderley-Britt’s coronary heart: A partnership with Volunteers of America, offering meals to economically weak youngsters.

(Christopher Cherrington | The Salt Lake Tribune)

“We developed a relationship with VOA in 2020, donating recent meals that’s of the identical high quality that we give to our company — that’s vital for us,” Wanderly-Britt stated.

Each week, her workers prepares floor beef and pasta, natural salad greens and bread. The menu was fastidiously thought of to maximise vitamins and keep away from triggering meals allergy symptoms (no seafood, for example). Spices are averted, since youngsters have extra delicate palates.

On Monday mornings, 360 drops off meals on the VOA Ladies and Kids’s Middle in Murray, and on Tuesdays, sy the VOA Youth Middle in Salt Lake Metropolis. As soon as COVID-19 numbers come down, Wanderly-Britt stated, they wish to ship its workers to cook dinner on-site. The corporate can also be in search of a nonprofit accomplice in Ogden, in order that they’ll serve that group, too.

“One thing we all the time say to our workers, that you must put love behind it whenever you’re cooking, as a result of folks will style it on the opposite finish,” she stated. “The identical love we put in to cook dinner the meals for our company, we put in to make the VOA meals. I believe it’s really extra vital to place love, extra love, into this, since you’re giving another person hope, proper? To allow them to get again on their ft and get again on observe.”

Not letting meals go to waste

Waste Much less Options, a nonprofit working since 2018, is within the enterprise of rescuing meals earlier than it goes to the landfill.

Because the group began, stated founder Dana Williamson, Waste Much less has rescued 587,000 kilos of meals — about 489,000 meals’ value. The group has a cadre of volunteers who can rescue meals about to be thrown out, and a community of companies — grocery shops, caterers, produce wholesalers, even the Downtown Farmers Market — that donate their leftover items.

Waste Much less not too long ago acquired a $20,000 grant from 100 Ladies Who Care, a Salt Lake Metropolis civic group, to launch a pilot program with the Boys & Ladies Golf equipment of Larger Salt Lake — to supply ready-to-eat meals comprised of rescued meals.

(Waste Much less Options) Prepared-to-eat meals, comprised of rescued meals, are ready for supply to households coping with meals insecurity — as a part of a pilot program organized by Waste Much less Options and the Boys & Ladies Golf equipment of Larger Salt Lake.

Williamson, who serves on the Boys & Ladies Golf equipment’ board, stated this system addresses a needn’t all the time acknowledged: The dearth of a spot, or time, to cook dinner.

“There’s a barrier typically in having the ability to make the most of meals in a straightforward and handy manner,” stated Amanda Ree Hughes, president of Boys & Ladies Golf equipment of Larger Salt Lake. “In the event that they don’t have a manner of making ready meals, or an understanding of find out how to use it, then it’s not likely fixing their downside.”

Some households are in transitional housing, or residing in motels, or outright experiencing homelessness. They could not have entry to a full kitchen, or could also be working so many hours they don’t have time to cook dinner. That drives many to depend on unhealthy comfort meals.

“We all know there’s a correlation between meals insecurity and weight problems,” Hughes stated. “What are you able to repair if you happen to solely have entry to a microwave? You get meals which can be processed and excessive sugar, excessive salt, excessive fats. Maintaining a healthy diet prices some huge cash — recent produce, recent meats, issues like that.”

This system now serves 15 households every week by the Midvale Boys & Ladies Membership, and there are plans to increase if the pilot is profitable. Williamson works with chef Adam Kreisel of Chaia Cucina, who plans menus primarily based on what meals occurs to be out there from the present donors, Restaurant Depot and the U.S. Meals Retailer. These provides are taken to a rented business kitchen each Tuesday.

“We name Adam and say, ‘Right here’s what we’ve obtained, what do you suppose we must always make?’” Williamson stated. “My favourite, as a result of it was such a shock to me, was we had some candy potatoes, which we roasted, and dug out the insides and mashed. He used that in a pasta sauce. It was an exquisite orange colour. And we snuck in some further greens that manner.”

The meals is cooled in a single day, and delivered by volunteers on Wednesdays. “Now we have them go in and package deal it,” Williamson stated. “One among our huge issues is feeding folks with dignity, so we put good labels on it, and current an merchandise that we expect is restaurant-worthy.”

Williamson’s expertise — rescuing greater than a half-million kilos of meals over the past 4 years — illustrates what she sees because the true nature of meals insecurity in America.

“It’s not a provide downside,” she stated. “It’s a distribution downside.”

How one can assist

Bott, on the meals financial institution, stated any group combating meals insecurity wants “the massive three: meals, time, and cash.”

• The Utah Meals Financial institution is accepting volunteers, and all the time welcomes meals donations.

“A straightforward rule of thumb, if you happen to’re purchasing and shopping for one thing your loved ones would take pleasure in, double up,” Bott stated. “Lots of the grocery shops all through the state have a barrel or a field by the entrance door, and you should buy merchandise and go away them proper there.”

Go to UtahFoodBank.org for data on find out how to make a donation.

• Waste Much less Options wants volunteers to help with the ready meal program for Boys & Ladies Membership. (A meals handler’s allow is a requirement to take part.) The group is also in search of meals donors, together with yard gardeners who can drop further produce at coolers situated all through the metro space through the rising season. “As spring comes, we’re trying to funnel the meals from the farmers’ market and yard gardeners,” Williams says.

Go to wastelesssolutions.org to learn to assist.

• The Boys & Ladies Membership of Larger Salt Lake is accepting extra volunteers as COVID-19 case numbers drop. Its best want is for volunteers to serve snacks and meals at golf equipment, to unlock workers to work instantly with youngsters. Volunteers should bear a background examine and an orientation course of, and should decide to an everyday schedule. “One or two days every week for an hour or two at a time could be the perfect scenario proper now,” Hughes stated.

To volunteer, name the administration workplace at 801-322-4411, or contact diet specialist Ryan Van Brunt at rvanbrunt@gslclubs.org.